Separate access to information from decision-making authority
An authorization can permit a named person to receive health information. That is different from appointing someone to make healthcare decisions. Under HIPAA, authority under state law may make someone a personal representative for relevant information; a separate information-sharing authorization alone does not appoint a healthcare decision-maker. Nor should you assume that an agent always needs a separate HIPAA authorization.
Keep the documents’ jobs distinct: a HIPAA authorization concerns information access, while a healthcare power of attorney or advance directive addresses healthcare authority and preferences. The right combination depends on what you want each person to be able to do.
Choose recipients, scope, and duration deliberately
Start with the practical question: who should be able to receive information, and for what purpose? You may want to consider whether the same people should receive the same information, whether access should be broad or limited, and how long the arrangement should remain useful. These are planning choices to discuss when preparing the document—not assumptions about what a particular provider or form will accept.
Compare your intended information recipients with the agent and alternate named in your healthcare documents. They may be the same people, but one role does not automatically answer every question about another role. CFPB guidance likewise distinguishes powers-of-attorney agents, court-appointed guardians or conservators, trustees, and government-appointed benefit fiduciaries.
Prepare a one-page sharing plan
Before a planning conversation, make a simple table with four columns: person, information they may need, reason they may need it, and when you want access to begin or end. Add a note beside each person identifying any separate role you intend them to have, such as healthcare agent or alternate. This comparison makes gaps and overlap easier to spot without treating information access as decision-making authority.
Bring the table alongside copies of your current healthcare power of attorney or advance directive, if you have them. The Tennessee Advance Directive for Health Care form addresses an agent or alternate and healthcare preferences, and includes instructions about signing and sharing copies. Review how your documents work together rather than assuming one replaces another.
- Check names and contact details for each intended recipient.
- Mark any limits or timing preferences you want to discuss.
- Identify who should make healthcare decisions, if anyone, separately from who should receive information.
- Note existing documents and any uncertainty about how they fit together.
Questions to resolve before signing
Ask whether the proposed authorization matches the information access you intend, whether its scope and duration are clear, and how it relates to your healthcare agent and alternate. Ask what document a provider may need to see and how copies should be shared. If you want one person to receive information but another to make healthcare decisions, say so explicitly during planning.
Dale Law Group, PLLC, led by Carolyn D. Dale, offers HIPAA authorization planning as part of its Tennessee estate-planning services. The firm’s only office is in Murfreesboro; Lookout Mountain is a Tennessee service-area location, not a firm office.
Questions to bring to the discussion
Does a HIPAA authorization make someone my healthcare decision-maker?
No. The authorization alone does not appoint a decision-maker. Healthcare authority and information access are distinct, though state-law healthcare authority may make someone a HIPAA personal representative.
Should my healthcare agent also be named on an authorization?
That depends on your intended information-sharing plan and applicable authority. Compare the agent’s role with the recipients and scope you want, rather than assuming a separate authorization is always required or unnecessary.
Discuss your next step with Dale Law Group
Begin with a brief, non-confidential overview. The firm will discuss your needs and appointment arrangements.
General information, not advice for a particular situation. Sending an inquiry does not create an attorney-client relationship.